System ArchitectureSolution Architect

What is the difference between monolithic and service-oriented architectures? In which cases is it better to use one approach or the other?

Pass interviews with Hintsage AI assistant

Answer.

Monolithic architecture implies that all functionalities of the application are assembled in a single codebase that is developed and deployed together.

Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA), and in particular microservices, is an approach where the application consists of a set of modules that interact through well-defined interfaces (usually networked).

When monolithic is advantageous:

  • Small startup or MVP
  • The application has few interacting modules
  • Simplicity in management and deployment is essential

When SOA is advantageous:

  • Large or growing applications with differing teams and technologies
  • Frequent changes are required in individual modules
  • There is a need for increased fault tolerance and scalability

Example comparison: Monolithic:

public class Application { public static void main(String[] args){ UserService userService = new UserService(); OrderService orderService = new OrderService(); // Order and user logic — everything in one application } }

SOA — interaction via API:

GET /user/42 # request to user service GET /order/532 # request to order service

Key features:

  • One process — easier deployment, harder to maintain scalability
  • Clear separation of roles and responsibilities between services
  • System integration and relationship testing are required

Tricky questions.

Does SOA share a database between services?

Typically, services share data for weak coupling. Shared databases are acceptable during migration phases, but ideally each service has its separate database.

Is monolithic always worse in performance?

No, a monolith can be more performant at smaller scales, as there are no unnecessary network calls and memory separation.

Can a monolith be converted to microservices "all at once"?

No, typically the transition is made in phases, starting with defining context boundaries and transforming them into services.