Stability of automated tests is an important aspect of confident CI/CD and trust in automation.
Background
Initially, automated tests were run manually, and instability did not interfere much. With the growth in the number of tests and integration into pipelines, the emergence of flaky tests (tests that sometimes fail for no apparent reason) has become a significant issue.
Problem
Flaky tests lead to:
Solution
What helps:
Example of using waits:
WebDriverWait(driver, 10).until( EC.presence_of_element_located((By.ID, "result")) )
Key Features:
Will mass retry solve the problem of flaky tests?
No, this is just a temporary "patching holes". It does not eliminate the cause — it only masks existing problems.
Can automated tests be run only at night to avoid failures due to load?
Running tests at night will not eliminate instability; it will only reduce the likelihood; the problem remains and must be addressed.
Should all flaky tests be deleted immediately?
No. It is better to try to localize the cause and fix it — only delete if it cannot be stabilized or if it is an outdated, irrelevant test.
The team resorted to mass retry of tests that constantly flaked. As a result, the list of "green" tests increased, but the quality of automated tests did not improve — bugs were missed.
Pros:
Cons:
The team found and described systematic flaky causes: uncleaned data, UI delays, network failures. They fixed the architecture, added sensible waits, configured the environment — the number of unstable tests sharply decreased.
Pros:
Cons: